Comments on: I love the smell of roasting music critics in the morning http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/ RPGs. Trains, and bands that write 12 minute songs about Hobbits Thu, 04 Dec 2008 05:45:51 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.3 By: Where Worlds Collide » Blog Archive » Another victory in the Prog Wars? http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-3543 Where Worlds Collide » Blog Archive » Another victory in the Prog Wars? Fri, 10 Oct 2008 22:37:18 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-3543 [...] We never managed to get an apology out of Tony Naylor. [...] […] We never managed to get an apology out of Tony Naylor. […]

]]> By: bob http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2907 bob Sun, 10 Feb 2008 17:41:32 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2907 Actually Stuart stayed pretty quiet IIRC. In fact, he's quite a big fan of prog - Gentle Giant are one of his favourite bands and I saw him in the foyer waiting to go into a Yes gig about 3 or 4 years ago. Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder aren't really my thing, but I wouldn't condemn anyone for liking them. They clearly did some work that is worthy of respect even if I don't find much in it to match my tastes. But I don't think we should turn it into an either/or thing; otherwise we make the same mistake as the Guardian journalist. Actually Stuart stayed pretty quiet IIRC.

In fact, he’s quite a big fan of prog - Gentle Giant are one of his favourite bands and I saw him in the foyer waiting to go into a Yes gig about 3 or 4 years ago.

Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder aren’t really my thing, but I wouldn’t condemn anyone for liking them. They clearly did some work that is worthy of respect even if I don’t find much in it to match my tastes. But I don’t think we should turn it into an either/or thing; otherwise we make the same mistake as the Guardian journalist.

]]> By: Barbara http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2870 Barbara Sat, 19 Jan 2008 14:39:43 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2870 Did you all see Stuart Maconie and David Quantick following the usual prog-bashing party line on Pop On Trial: The 70's? Then they predictably brown-nosed Stevie Wonder and Marvin Gaye, which was my cue to turn off. Did you all see Stuart Maconie and David Quantick following the usual prog-bashing party line on Pop On Trial: The 70’s? Then they predictably brown-nosed Stevie Wonder and Marvin Gaye, which was my cue to turn off.

]]> By: Tim Hall http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2867 Tim Hall Wed, 16 Jan 2008 23:27:54 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2867 And in another equally stupid blog today he admits to being in his early 30s. Which means he'd have been two or three years old in 1976. Too young to actually have been <i>there</i>. Explains why he's swallowed the revisionist narrative wholesale. And in another equally stupid blog today he admits to being in his early 30s. Which means he’d have been two or three years old in 1976. Too young to actually have been there. Explains why he’s swallowed the revisionist narrative wholesale.

]]> By: Tim Hall http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2865 Tim Hall Wed, 16 Jan 2008 20:47:39 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2865 >><i>I’ll cheerfully do a better job for nowt! </i> You already do. I pay more attention to your blog (among others) than I do to any music rag, even "Classic Rock" (a.k.a. Guns'N'Roses monthly) >>I’ll cheerfully do a better job for nowt!

You already do. I pay more attention to your blog (among others) than I do to any music rag, even “Classic Rock” (a.k.a. Guns’N'Roses monthly)

]]> By: HippyDave http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2861 HippyDave Tue, 15 Jan 2008 19:37:42 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2861 Oh, my. Fantastic! I haven't laughed like that for months. Well done, sir (and the other commenters, of course)... What an arse, eh? They actually pay a moron like that to write music reviews? Christ, I'll cheerfully do a better job for nowt! :-) Oh, my. Fantastic! I haven’t laughed like that for months. Well done, sir (and the other commenters, of course)…

What an arse, eh? They actually pay a moron like that to write music reviews? Christ, I’ll cheerfully do a better job for nowt! :-)

]]> By: Tim Hall http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2849 Tim Hall Sat, 12 Jan 2008 21:00:32 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2849 Note how so many commentors are both better writers and better framers of arguments than Naylor. And unlike him, none of them were paid for it (I don't *think* any of them were Guardian staffers, although one or two might have been). Shows how peer-to-peer nature of the Blogosphere is better in many ways than the top-down model of dead tree journalism. Note how so many commentors are both better writers and better framers of arguments than Naylor. And unlike him, none of them were paid for it (I don’t *think* any of them were Guardian staffers, although one or two might have been).

Shows how peer-to-peer nature of the Blogosphere is better in many ways than the top-down model of dead tree journalism.

]]> By: NRT http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2848 NRT Sat, 12 Jan 2008 19:54:30 +0000 http://www.kalyr.com/weblog/2008/01/12/i-love-the-smell-of-roasting-music-critics-in-the-morning/#comment-2848 Nope, you're wrong. ;) Couldn't agree more. Naylor was acting like an arse; his <i>'more-NME-than-thou'</i> attitude would have been laughable if the Guardian hadn't paid him to spout it. Okay, normally I would recommend just ignoring that sort of nonsense (literally non-sense), but a few prods got him frothing and nicely destroyed his credibility as a music reviewer (and remember, as the NME says, credibility is all). Well done. Nope, you’re wrong. ;)

Couldn’t agree more. Naylor was acting like an arse; his ‘more-NME-than-thou’ attitude would have been laughable if the Guardian hadn’t paid him to spout it. Okay, normally I would recommend just ignoring that sort of nonsense (literally non-sense), but a few prods got him frothing and nicely destroyed his credibility as a music reviewer (and remember, as the NME says, credibility is all). Well done.

]]>