Marillion – 10 of the best

marillion

I’ve got another Ten of the Best features in The Guardian, this time for Marillion.

Attempting to condense thirty-five years and sixteen album’s worth of music into just ten songs is next to impossible, and the the list went through a lot of permutations before settling on the final ten.

As people ought to have realised by now, I always avoid the Big Hit that everbody knows, because what’s the point? There are so many other riches in the back catalogue. There’s nothing from their biggest-selling album, “Misplaced Childhood”, which is an obvious omission, but so much of it only works in the context of the whole album. “Bitter Suite”, a candidate on the initial longlist didn’t make the cut because it doesn’t work as a standalone song, ending abruptly when it seques into “Heart of Lothian”.

It was also a decision right from the beginning for the split between Fish -era and H-era songs to reflect the number of albums, which was always going to mean Fish-era songs would be in the minority. Some people will not like that.

And, just as predicted, the very first comment mentions Grendel…

This entry was posted in Music Opinion and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Marillion – 10 of the best

  1. Tom B says:

    Thanks Tim,
    As someone who has all four Fish-era albums but only two Hogarth ones, this was a chance to find out a bit more about what I may have been missing out on. I loved This is the 21st Century so I guess Anaraknophobia might be the album I go for next, but everyone in the comments was raving about Brave so I’m torn …

  2. ngv says:

    Having been thinking about this far too long over the last fortnight

    Grendel (sorry!), Incubus, Cinderella Search, The Last Straw, Seasons End, Brave (heartbreaks every time H sings “she’s gone now”) , Afraid of Sunlight, Accidental Man, Deserve (it’s Marillion with a saxophone!), Neverland

    Honourable mention for Assasing but didn’t want to put two from the same album.