Roskilde vs. Glastonbury

The Glastonbury festival is one of those things that divides opinion amongst music fans. On one side there are those that complain that the bill is always far too corporate and indie-centric. On the other side there are those who dismiss the complainers as genre snobs, merely sneering at the mainstream from the sidelines.

The BBC have a lot to answer for. Their coverage always seems to contain far too much of the intensely annoying Jo Whiley fawning over the latest overrated three-chord wonder and far too little of the eclectic variety taking place across the many small stages. But it’s impossible to ignore the fact that rock and metal are very conspicuous by the absence from the festival.

So the bill of the Roskilde Festival in Denmark makes an interesting comparison with that of Glastonbury. There are many of the same names, but you’ll also see names like Iron Maiden, Mastodon, Slipknot and Judas Priest alongside the likes of Oasis and The Arctic Monkeys. It’s all but impossible to imagine any of the former making an appearance on the Glastonbury bill.

Does this reflect something fundamentally different about the music scene on the Continent?  Are rock and metal seen as a part of the musical mainstream in a way they are not in Britain?  Or does the British musical establishment of which Glastonbury is an important part just hate rock and metal?

This entry was posted in Music Opinion and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Roskilde vs. Glastonbury

  1. Sam Lewis says:

    I would say that is MOSTLY the fact that the scene is just much different on the continent. Bands that don’t make the album charts in the UK do much better in Europe and they also tend to play much bigger venues. I think people in Europe are generally more open to music than people here in the UK. I don’t think metal has the same stigma there so people are more likely to enjoy both Slipknot and Oasis :)

  2. PaulE says:

    The Beeb’s “alternative” music output is geared towards an appearance of openness and eclectic choices. The oddball acts seem to act as a cover for the otherwise wall-to-wall Indie bands.