Category Archives: Music

Reviews, news, photos, thoughts and opinions about music, with a particular emphasis on the UK progressive rock scene.

And People Accuse Prog of Conservatism?

A link to a press release for a new band it might be better not to name turned up in my Twitter feed.

A band who struck a chord with each other and found a common ground in the love they have for the same music – bands with identities and guitars!

Wow! Guitars! Whatever will they think of next? Will they actually learn to play them?

The guys are armed with a strong identity and craft for song writing. They brim with a confidence not seen since the Britpop days with songs that reach to grab you from the intro and don’t let you go till the last note is viciously struck in a punk vein.

What can I say? With a press release as clichéd as that, can we assume the music is equally formulaic? And it’s the second time you’re used the word “identity” too. Does this perhaps imply an emphasis on style at the expense of content?

Lyrically they offer an insight into the social commentary and satire of contemporary suburban British life, with choruses to get you singing along and po-going the night away to your hearts content.

Let me guess. Songs about fights outside kebab shops on a Friday night. I bet nobody’s done that before…

They put on a captivating live show and are often described as a musical blend of Blur, Bloc Party and Wire. A juggernaut of a sound!

As a metal fan, I have trouble using the word “juggernaut” when it’s abundantly clear by now that we’re talking three-chord indie. Other vehicle descriptors might be more appropriate. How about “moped”?

I did listen to their promo on YouTube. Well, about 45 seconds of it, which was as much as I could stomach. It was every bit as bad as I feared; tedious, tuneless landfill indie-by-numbers. The breathless Nathan Barley style PR guff had inadvertently described it very well, but just not the way the author had intended.

People accuse progressive rock of being a conservative and backward-looking genre, and a lot of it is probably guilty as changed. But in my mind 90s Britpop was a far worse offender with its insular parochialism and extremely limited palette of musical influences. Much of it came over as a pastiche of the same second-division guitar pop that represented the “stagnant musical forms” Steve Hackett famously wanted to get away from back in 1970, combined with a bit of watered-down punk shorn of the visceral energy that was really the whole point of punk.

It was bad enough in the 1990s. Making the same sort of music in 2012 is a pastiche of a pastiche. That ship has not so much already sailed as been consigned to the breaker’s yard.

Posted in Music, Thoughts and Opinions | Tagged | Leave a comment

Cambridge Rock Festival Springfest Cancelled

Sad news today that the spring edition of the Cambridge Rock Festival, which was to have featured Chantel McGregor, Karnataka, Winter in Eden and Ebony Tower, among many others, has been cancelled because the site is waterlogged after the recent heavy rain.

As stated on the CRF website:

It is with deep regret that The Cambridge Rock Festival has had to cancel it’s Spring Edition Festival, which should have taken place 27-28-29 April (this coming weekend). Due to adverse weather conditions preventing the infrastructure being installed.

However The Cambridge Rock Festival 2-3-4-5 August will still take place.

Very disappointing news, although holding a festival on an outdoor site this early in the season was always going to be a bit of a risk. The August festival is shaping up to be a good one, though, with a very strongly prog-orientated lineup this year, with Caravan, Focus, It Bites, Touchstone and Flanborough Head along with virtually the whole Mostly Autumn extended family of bands.

Posted in Music, Music News | 4 Comments

Crimson Sky, Reading, 31st March 2012

Saturday 31st of March saw Reading’s Prog event of the year; a showcase gig featuring Crimson Sky marking the début of their new vocalist Jane Setter, co-headlining with Grey Lady Down, with support from John Mitchell of It Bites/Arena/*Frost fame. It took place in South Street Arts Centre, a lovely little venue five minutes from the centre of Reading.

Despite the competition the same night from Touchstone at the Peel and (because prog fans travel) Magenta up in Wath in South Yorkshire, there was still an appreciable-sized crowd. To emphasise that this was an event, not just a regular gig, we had a Master of Ceremonies in the form of Tinyfish’s Rob Ramsey, who certainly dressed for the occasion.

John Mitchell was originally billed to appear solo, but a couple of days before the gig it turned into a duo of him and keyboard player John Beck, making it half of It Bites. The pair of them put in an impressive performance combining recent It Bites tunes with some well-chosen covers; their take on Peter Gabriel’s “Here Comes The Flood” was spine-tingling.

Grey Lady Down were a 1990s band, one of the acts on the independent Cyclops label. Recently reformed after a ten year hiatus, and expanded to a six-piece with twin guitars, they played a tight, powerful and quite heavy set. Highlights were the hard-rocking opener “And Finally”, and the intense “Paper Chains (the Crime Part 3)”, both from their 1997 album “Fear”. Even if their brand of 80s-style neo-prog wasn’t stunning original, they did deliver a passionate performance with some strong material. It’s nice to see them back.

Crimson Sky’s appearance was their first since a very poorly-attended gig in Swindon more than a year ago. That was the one and only live appearance of the short-lived lineup with Janey Summer on vocals, replacement for Holly Thody who’d appeared on their one album to date, “Misunderstood”. Tonight was the first live appearance by an all-new incarnation of the band, with Jane Setter taking up the microphone as their third lead singer.

Crimson Sky fall within the broad spectrum of progressive rock, but while they have the traditional 5-piece prog lineup of vocals-guitar-keys-bass-drums they’re not a generic neo-prog band. They’re not averse to the occasional classically-derived flourish or widdly keyboard solo but there’s also something of a spiky 80s new-wave edge on quite a few songs, and their sound has a lot more space in the mix compared with GLD’s wall-of-sound approach. The dominant instrumental sound is Martin Leamon’s guitar playing, whether it’s indie-style jangle, metallic riffage or fluid jazz-flavoured solos. Much of the time he’s soloing throughout the song behind the vocal rather than playing straightforward chord progressions.

I’d seen Jane Setter fronting a local prog covers band (yes, there are such things!) a few times in the Reading area, and this gig is clearly a significant step up to a bigger stage. She not only has a great voice, but combines it with a strong stage presence. With much of the set taken from “Misunderstood” she rose to the challenge of taking another singer’s material and making it hers without changing the songs out of all recognition, something that’s easier said that done. Her style is a little more classic rock than Holly’s somewhat punky approach, which suits some songs better than others. But if one or two songs didn’t quite come off, there were many more that she completely owned.

They ended their enthusiastic performance with an encore of the epic “Misunderstood III”. It’s clear that Crimson Sky are back. The smiles of the faces of all the band throughout the gig really said it all.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , , | 7 Comments

Mostly Autumn 2012 Tour Dates

It’s unusual for Mostly Autumn not to tour in May; this year they’ve concentrating their efforts on recording their new album “The Ghost Moon Orchestra” rather than gigging at weekends and recording during the week as they did a couple of years ago. The band had previously announced they’d be touring in September. Now they’ve announced the dates for the second part of the year, in two legs, one in September, the second in December.

  • Sunday 5 August 2012 – Cambridge Rock Festival
  • Saturday 1 September 2012 – O2 Academy Islington, London
  • Sunday 2 September 2012 – Robin 2, Bilston
  • Friday 7 September 2012 – The Sage, Gateshead
  • Saturday 8 September 2012 – The Met, Bury
  • Sunday 9 September 2012 – Cathouse, Glasgow
  • Friday 14 September 2012 – Spirit of 66, Verviers, Belgium
  • Saturday 15 September 2012 – de Boerderij, Zoetermeer, The Netherlands
  • Friday 28 September 2012 – The Wharf, Tavistock
  • Saturday 29 September 2012 – The Gate, Cardiff
  • Sunday 30 September 2012 – Bath Komedia
  • Wednesday 5 December 2012 – The Stables, Milton Keynes
  • Thursday 6 December 2012 – The Grand Opera House, York
  • Friday 7 December 2012 – Arts Centre, Norwich
  • Saturday 8 December 2012 – CRS, Montgomery Hall, Wath
  • Sunday 9 December 2012 – Robin 2, Bilston
  • Monday 10 December 2012 – The Brook, Southampton

A few interesting points. First, the long-announced Cambridge Rock Festival appearance looks like it’s going to be the first live airing of the new material, much like the band débuted much of “Go Well Diamond Heart” at the Progbury festival in 2010. Second, we see the first London headline appearance in more than three years; their last two London shows have been a support slot for Wishbone Ash (They blew them off stage!) and a co-headliner with It Bites (Honours a bit more even on that one).

Finally, the traditional end-of-year York gig is midweek; not sure how that will go down with the fans who traditionally make a weekend in York for that gig. At the moment I have no idea what anyone else in the “scene” has planned for that time; it may be there will be a Stolen Earth or Heather Findlay Band gig scheduled for the Friday. We shall have to see…

Update: Not on the MA website yes, but Holmfirth Picturedrome are advertising an additional show on Friday 31st August. No idea if there are any others still to be confirmed.

Posted in Music, Music News | Tagged | 7 Comments

The Reasoning – And Another Thing

The news of the disappearance of guitarist Owain Roberts, and the huge and ongoing fan campaign to spread the word and help find him has rather overshadowed the fact that the band have a new record out. Indeed, the band sent out the signed pre-order copies just days before he disappeared.

Although the band released a live album “The Bottle of Gettysburg” in 2011, and the album of reworkings of existing songs “Acoustically Speaking” late in 2010, this four track EP is the first release of all-new material since “Adverse Camber” two years ago. It’s also the first studio recording by the slimmed-down five piece version of the band with Owain Roberts as sole guitarist and Rachel Cohen as sole lead vocalist.

The opener “One By One” sets the tone. Beginning with chiming guitar and a vocal melody with an echo of their earlier “Dark Angel”, it combines atmospheric verses with a rockier chorus and a brief instrumental break of interplaying guitar and keys. It’s all over in less than four minutes, but seems to pack an awful lot of music into so short a time. In contrast, “Pale Criminal” is an out-and-out ballad. With another beautiful vocal melody from Rachel Cohen it’s a song that wouldn’t have sounded out of place on Karnataka’s “Delicate Flame of Desire”.

“Apophenia” and “20 Grams” round off the EP in similar vein, mid-tempo numbers combining delicate vocal melodies with restrained instrumental virtuosity from Owain Roberts and keyboardist Tony Turrell. Lyrics cover things like “the experience of seeing meaningful patterns or connections in random or meaningless data” and Duncan MacDougall’s rather strange theories of the weight of the human soul. Not your typical rock’n'roll fare at all.

The whole EP has a softer, more pared-back sound, with shorter songs reining in the prog-metal excesses of their recent past. There’s still plenty of depth in the arrangements, with a few nods to latter-day Marillion and Rush. But now Rachel Cohen’s vocals are given much more space to breathe, no longer in any danger of being swamped by the instrumentation. It’s a case of less being more. Even if none of the four songs quite reach the highest points of the first two albums, the result is nevertheless a more coherent and focussed effort than their last studio album, and it takes a very different musical direction from their early work.

The band are back in the studio now recording a full-length album slated for release in September, which will be the band’s first release under their new record deal Esoteric Antenna. In the meantime, this EP, their last self-released recording under the imprint of Comet Records, is available from the band’s website.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | 2 Comments

Mermaid Kiss – Circles of Fire

It’s been a long time since there’s been any activity from the Mermaid Kiss camp, but they’ve just released a new download single, “Circles of Fire”. It’s taken from their forthcoming album “Another Country”, the culmination of their “American Images” project.

Those of you who saw the semi-acoustic version of the band supporting Panic Room, Breathing Space or The Reasoning back in 2008 may well remember this song, as it featured in the live set. It’s a great showcase for Evelyn Downing’s very distinctive vocal style, Although acoustic instruments still feature heavily with Jamie Field’s guitar and Wendy Marks’ beautiful flute playing, here it’s expanded into a full band version culminating in a great solo from lead guitarist Pete West. As a slightly harder-edged Mermaid Kiss with more emphasis on guitar compared with the keyboard-led atmospherics of their last full-length album “Etarlis”, it’s in interesting taster for the forthcoming album.

It’s available for download from CD Baby.

Posted in Music, Music News, Record Reviews | Tagged | Leave a comment

Panic Room – S K I N

Panic Room have announced the title and revealed the cover artwork for their third album. Called S K I N, the album will be released in June, and details of the pre-order will be announced shortly. In the band’s words “The album has a vast and expansive feel : gracefully weaving its way through rock-solid riffs and potent grooves, there are moments of intense power, heart-stopping gravity, and delicate beauty”.

If the rest of the album is anything like as good as the two songs played live last years (and I’m sure it will be), this is well worth waiting for.

Posted in Music, Music News | Tagged | Leave a comment

Piracy is Killing Music – A Big Lie?

So, where does the news that Adele’s “21″ has now outsold Pink Floyd’s legendary “Dark Side of the Moon” leave the idea that downloading is killing music?

It’s increasingly looking like a big lie.

While I have no figures in front of me (and distrust any numbers quoted by Big Music), there is a lot of evidence that overall music sales aren’t declining at all. What has really been happening is that the major labels have been losing market share. During the boom years they made huge profits selling overpriced CDs, and eventually grew lazy and complacent. Too much of the music they released was formulaic cookie-cutter “product” that took few risks, aimed at people who buy all their music in supermarkets, and by controlling access to the mass media they prevented anything else from being heard. The coming of broadband internet radically changed the way people discovered and consumed music, and the majors were very slow in adapting their business models to take advantage of new methods of distribution. The lost out to those that did, and the likes of iTunes ate their lunch.

Rather than develop newer business models, they screamed “piracy!” and lobbied corrupt politicians to pass draconian protectionist legislation.

I’m now starting to believe that laws like America’s Stop Internet Piracy Act and Britain’s Digital Economy Act were never really about “piracy” at all. The way such laws have the potential to cripple parts of the net used by independent musicians to promote and distributed their work wasn’t just an unfortunate side effect, it was the whole point. “Piracy” was never more than a smokescreen, a lie spun to people like Peter Mandelson.

Just think about it. Which of these two activities hurts the major labels more?

  1. “Illegally” downloading an album you probably would never have bought, listening to it once and thinking “meh”.
  2. Paying 10 quid for an independently released record, leaving you with less to spend on the majors’ music?

I rest my case

Posted in Music, Thoughts and Opinions | Tagged | 6 Comments

Owain Roberts is missing

Owain Roberts of The Reasoning at Bury Met

Owain Roberts, guitarist from the Reasoning (above photo from 2010) has gone missing, and friends, family and bandmates are getting increasingly concerned for his safely. From the Dyfed and Powys Police website:

The family of 36 year old Owain Mon Roberts are increasingly concerned for his safety.

Owain has not been seen since Saturday morning, 10th March 2012.

Owain’s hair is greying particularly on the sides.  His front left tooth has a chip. He is of medium build with blue/grey eyes.  He may well have grown stubble by this time

The top he was last seen wearing has a round neck, and the cardigan he was wearing over it is a thick knit with a zip up front, with a quilted hood. The cardigan is a Topshop cardigan.

The bag he was carrying is grey in colour with orange stitching, and of canvas type material and is a shoulder bag, most likely to be worn across the front.

Owain is a sound technician with Theatr Mwldan in Cardigan

Anyone with information should call Dyfed Powys Police on 101 (or Outside Dyfed-Powys: 01267 222020)

Owain, if you’re reading this, please get in touch with the band and tell them you’re OK.

Update 14/3/12:

No news yet on Owain’s whereabouts, but the band posted this on Facebook yesterday.

The Reasoning have decided not to put the EP up for sale this week as a mark of respect to the current ongoing situation. It just would not feel right selling this EP until we had some positive news about Owain. …We have also shut down all operations to do with The Reasoning this week as well. None of the band will be in the studio at all. We just can’t concentrate and again, it doesn’t feel right.

We will assess again next week and take families’ opinions into account then make a decision from there. In the meantime, all that matters is obviously getting a firm lead as to Owain’s whereabouts. Thanks for understanding and until further notice, it’s all about bringing our friend home safe and sound.

Matt, Rach, Tony, and Jake xxxx

(Police information and link updated 14-Mar at 17:25)

Posted in Music, Music News | Tagged | Leave a comment

Prog-gate “The Prog Corruption Blog”

I really try to steer well clear of backstage politics in the Prog world. But sometimes things happen on public forums that leave me no choice.

There has been something of a ruction in the community over a mysterious blog calling itself the “Prog Corruption Blog”, which claimed to “try to address corruption, scamming, vote canvassing and poll rigging in the world of Progressive Rock Music as dedicated and professional artists are forced out of popularity polls and charts by PR driven outfits“. There was but a single post, which made the claim that the reader’s poll in Classic Rock Presents Prog had been rigged in favour of Panic Room and The Reasoning, two bands recently signed by Esoteric Antenna. The whole thing reeked of an agenda, and read like the work of someone with an axe to grind against either the bands, the label, or both.

I learned of this blog from a link posted in the comments on another post in this blog, I immediately bought it to the attention of CRPP and two of the bands because I felt they needed to know. To say that there was then a significant sewage/ventilation device interface incident would be an understatement. Certainly some of those parties considered the contents of that blog libellous, and there was talk of lawyers.

A few hours later, after a number of angry comments including some from a member of one of those bands, the entire site disappeared.

If you read the whole thing before it got taken down, it was less an attack on the CRPP Poll, and more a direct attack on the professional integrity of two bands and their record company. There was also an implied personal attack on Panic Room’s frontwoman Anne-Marie Helder, suggesting that she did not deserve the Best Female Vocalist of 2011 award because the band “had played no more than half a dozen pub gigs”. (Obviously untrue, we’ll get to that later)

It’s now being suggested that the author writing under the false name of “Beverly Myers” is in fact male. I’m not going to argue with someone with a Master’s degree in psychology on that point. It’s notable that the (probably male) author adopted a voice that read like a crude caricature of 1980s hairy-armpit feminism to make his dubious points. I now believe he has a misogynistic agenda – not only are two of the bands female-fronted, but the record company is also run by a woman.

Given that the author has lied about his identity, nothing else can be taken at face value. The whole thing is full of distortions, half-truths and outright lies which cannot be put down to mere poor research. It should certainly not be dismissed as “a bit of harmless internet fun” – it’s a clear and deliberate attempt to damage several people’s means of earning a living. It’s already diverted a lot of their time and energy away from creating and promoting their music towards countering these malicious lies.

One of the bands has also dropped hints that they have strong suspicions as to the identity of the perpetrators (note the use of the plural here). While I don’t want to speculate on their specific identity, it does feel like the work of a fan or maybe even a member of a prog band made up of ugly blokes who’s bitter that the record label had passed over their dated 80s-style neo-prog in favour of two bands in question. That would put the sneering references to “bands fronted by pretty girls”, “beauty contests” and “they aren’t proper prog” in to context.

Somehow I don’t think we’ve heard the last of this by a long way.

Posted in Music, Thoughts and Opinions | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments