Muse – 2nd Law

Muse 2nd LawI’m sometimes accused of only liking obscure prog-rock bands who sing about Hobbits in 9/8 time. One Guardian music journalist who shall remain nameless has called me the “Prog Taliban” and claimed that I don’t like pop music.

So why am I reviewing a Muse album? Because, despite the fact that they’ve headlined the indie-centric Glastonbury Festival and you can probably get their albums in Asda, Muse are a really prog-rock band.

Opener “Supremacy” begins with a dirty Jack White style guitar riff accompanied by marching Dream Theater keyboards before moving to a classically-inspired vocal melody, with a guitar solo repeating the same motif. There’s something very Prog about the whole thing.

And it goes on like that. Yes, there still are plenty of homages to Queen, starting with the pseudo-dubstep “I Want To Break Free” of “Madness”. Then there’s the disco-funk of “Panic Station”. There are nods to U2. But “Animals”, with it’s wonderful rippling guitar could easily have come from a recent Marillion album. The wide-screen atmospherics of “Save Me” recall recent Anathema, and some of the guitars remind me of mid-period Genesis. The cinematic two-part title track that closes the album is just monstrous with it’s huge choirs and Pink Floyd-style voiceovers.

This is an album that mixes pop, metal, electronica with grandiose classical sweeps and arpeggios. A lot of it is bombastic and completely over the top, but it wouldn’t really be a Muse album if it wasn’t. They’ve got a pop sensibility; three or four minute songs with big choruses. But they pack so many musical ideas into those three or four minutes.

The way the album mixes bits of many different genres to produce something more than the sum of parts reminds me of Panic Room’s SKIN. Yes, there are obvious homages to other bands which have drawn comparisons with Oasis’ pillaging of rock history. But Muse draw from a far, far broader sonic palette than simple meat-and-potatoes guitar rock. The result is an album that ought to appeal to any self-respecting prog-rock fan.

This entry was posted in Record Reviews and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Muse – 2nd Law

  1. Chuk says:

    I’ve been considering going to see them when they come to town.
    (Speaking of Oasis, saw Noel Gallagher’s High-Flying Birds on Thursday. Basically seemed like Oasis with a slightly different singer. The new songs really sound a lot like something they might have progressed to.)

  2. BeastiePsy says:

    Couldn’t agree more with the majority of this. I find it laughable that the general public seem to have been up in arms about Muse’s assimilation of a few ideas from the worlds of dubstep, psytrance and glitch (the world’s oddest solicitors, maybe?), yet those of us with a proggy disposition just sit back, applaud their audacity and see if it works. And, to my mind, it works handsomely. Never my favourite band in the past, I thoroughly look forward to seeing them, having been convincingly sucked into their world this time round.
    One thing though, to compare Muse’s experimentation to Panic Room? Really? I can only assume that I received the wrong CD in the Panic Room case.

  3. Emma says:

    I can’t wait to see them live next month! I like how different this album is compared to their others. Also, I just came across a cover of “Supermassive Black Hole” done by 2 guys under the name 2 Cello, and I was blow away at how they nailed it (considering they play cellos). Definitely check it out! http://bit.ly/V6XRDj