James Worrad and The Waste-Ground

James Worrad writes in general agreement with an earlier post by Mark E Lawrence on the politicisation of SF fandom.

For my own part, jumping on the right wing Sad puppies foam-fest is utterly, comprehensively unthinkable. Just no. Writing impassioned common-all-garden social justice speeches is a lot more attractive (I agree on the basic stuff after all. I consider myself left wing) and in my needier moments I’ve thought about doing so. But, ultimately, I feel it would be to betray the multicultural British city that raised me (Oddly, social justice terms and philosophies become more impractical the deeper into a multicultural provincial UK city you go, in the same manner you saw less and less jingoism and flag-waving the closer you got to the trenches in World War 1. People are too busy just getting on with things).

I have a lot of sympathy for this. I have noticed that his post coming under fire from some of the usual suspects on Twitter. which is predictable if depressing.  It gives the impression that the SF world is dominated by two rival cliques who wear rheir (American) politics on their sleeves, and those who aren’t willing to adopt the dogmas of either tribe are feeling  increasingly alienated. When you hear people implying that being a political moderate is a symptom of privilege…

Last year I bought some recently-released SF/F novels without waiting for them to come out in paperback, with a view of nominating one or more them for a Hugo award, as a supporting member. But I’m come to the conclusion that I’d probably be wasting my money. What’s the point of paying good money to nominate something you think is worthy, only to find its nomination was championed by the wrong people, and either the author will be forced to decline the nomination or be ostracised, or it will be voted down by massed no-awards.

I’m still an SF reader. But when it comes to fandom, it’s a case of not my circus, not my monkeys.

This entry was posted in Religion and Politics, Science Fiction and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to James Worrad and The Waste-Ground

  1. James Worrad says:

    People are taking exception, huh? I hadn’t looked. Whenever that happens to me I always hear Michael Palin’s weary voice in Holy Grail when they go back into the hall with all the dead wedding guests in it and the survivors point and shout there he is, get him!

    ‘Oh bloody ‘ell…’

  2. Amadan says:

    Hey now, it isn’t just American politics. I see plenty of Brits who are proud SJW banner-wavers.

  3. Tim Hall says:

    Yes, we have our own neo-puritans too, but I still blame America for a lot of the political theory that informs their world view.