Tag Archives: Babymetal

I don’t care if Babymetal are cool, your article is toxic and alienating

As I’ve said before on this site, Babymetal are one of those bands who divide opinions. For everyone who finds their mix of metal and J-pop gloriously entertaining, there is another who thinks they’re too far removed from their narrow version of the spirit of metal. So when they were named as band of the year by Metal Hammer, it was all too predictable that some self-appointed defenders of genre purity were not happy with the result.

Unfortunately the bottom-feeding clickbait media got hold of the story.

I won’t name the publication or link to it because quite frankly those sleazy hacks don’t deserve the clicks. When you use inflammatory language like “Metal bros losing their shit” and “Manbabies throwing tantrums” you make it clear you’re not interested in constructive discussion. Cherry-picking the posts from a handful of idiots and using them in an attempt to smear a far wider subculture for cheap outrage is little different from the way alt-right scandal sheets like Brietbart treat Islam.

You get a sinking feeling reading garbage like that. It’s disturbingly reminiscent of those “Gamers are Dead” articles that did so much to inflame the toxicity of GamerGate two years ago, and you wonder if they’re going out of their way to provoke an equivalent backlash from metal fans. I hope metal fandom is wise enough not to rise to the bait.

Social media gets a lot of the blame for the increasing toxicity of online discourse. But the online media that actively fans the flames of the culture wars for profit shares an awful lot of the blame, and this is yet another example.

Posted in Religion and Politics | Tagged , | Comments Off

Zero-Sum Fanboys?

Why do some many people put so much energy into hating things that simply aren’t for them rather then in celebrating the things they love?

Do they believe everything is a zero-sum game?

You see this in metal fandom every time Babymetal get mentioned. They’ve not to everyone’s taste, true, but the whole concept can be enjoyed as something entertainingly silly. But some metal fans seem offended by their very existence. You’d have thought the metal world was big and diverse enough to have room for Babymetals as well as Dimmu Borgirs and Napalm Deaths and Nightwishes and Opeths. But no, it seems one person’s entertainingly silly fun represents an existential threat to everything they hold dear. Why? It’s not as if they’re receiving massive and undeserved media hype that might otherwise have gone to Pig Destroyer.

There are parallels with the culture wars over the new Ghostbusters remake. But do we really want to go there?

Posted in Music Opinion | Tagged | Comments Off