kalyr.com

Continental Modeller Jumps the Shark

I'm not sure quite when Continental Modeller jumped the shark, but it has. The magazine has completely succumbed to the 'narrow gauge disease' that has afflicted it's parent magazine.

If you're interested in standard-gauge mainline modelling, especially with modern diesel and electric operation, January's issue is very thin indeed. They've gone into obscurity in a big way, the railway equivalent of the John Peel Show on an off-night. We have the following:

  • Six pages of Peruvian 3' gauge, with all photographs of the same class of loco.
  • Six more about narrow gauge line in Germany, 100% operated by railcars.
  • Four pages of scale drawings of a Bosnian Klose articulated tank engine (last one withdrawn in 1967) with an absurdly complicated system of connecting rods. Only a skilled engineer working in a large scale could hope to build one.
  • Four more pages of Cumbres and Toltec (3' again)
  • Four pages of a Dutch 60cm diorama.
  • Another couple of pages on a narrow gauge layout set in Cuba.
  • Another page wasted on a stupid 15" gauge tourist railway in Tasmania.

This has gone beyond parody. I'm beginning to think we'll be seeing more D&E era continental stuff in MRM!

Why are Peco Publications so obsessed with narrow gauge? The Railway Modeller often gets criticised for too much emphasis on narrow gauge, but recent issues of CM seem to indicate it's getting even worse. Not that I'm against narrow gauge in small doses, it's just that I object to two-thirds of what was once a worthwhile magazine to be taken up something that represents a tiny fraction of the world's railways.

Posted by TimHall at December 12, 2004 04:25 PM | TrackBack
Comments

And not a 14XX in sight! :-)

Posted by: Steve Jones on December 13, 2004 07:23 AM

I'm going to get continual grief from you over than 14XX, aren't I? I suppose I should build a model of Ashburton, just to spite you. :)

Posted by: Tim Hall on December 13, 2004 08:39 PM

S'pose you have to replace a marzipan 22 with something.

You could always model Meldon, lots of excuse for 73's, and if you have dead Farish 47's or 31's they would work as well.

Posted by: Martyn Read on December 14, 2004 01:05 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?



Links of the day
Sixteen Tons

Electric Nose talks coal wagons.

Ficticious Liveries

The AC Loco Group's Ficticious Liveries are back! SWT HSTs, BR Blue 66s and many more.

The hell inside carraige 346A

A London Firefighter tells of his story of the July 7th bombings.

Hatfield Fines

13 million pound fine for Balfour Beatty and Notwork Rail. But the ivory tower moonbats of the Adam Smith Institute who are ultimately to blame get off scot free...

The Great Hole of Tescos

"There was no light at the end of the tunnel". The Guardian has the 'hole' story.